Pizza Rating Hall of Fame

This is just a start.  I still have a lot of formatting to do.

Brand – Style Rating Price Price/Oz Review Post Date Purchased @ Honors
Dr Oetker – Pizza Mozzarella 10 $3.98 $0.35 3/1/16 HEB Best Pepperoni
American Flatbread – Ionian Awakening 10 $5.98 $0.64 1/14/16 HEB Best Multi-Topping: Tied
HEB – Pepperoni 10 $7.99 $0.46 3/18/17 HEB Best Non-Frozen
Monteli – Organic Margherita 10 $5.98 $0.44 4/20/17 HEB Best Multi-Topping: Tied
American Flatbread – Tomato Sauce & Three Cheese 9.9 $5.98 $0.66 4/28/16 HEB Best Multi-Topping: 2nd Place (Tied)
California Pizza Kitchen – Sicilian 9.9 $5.86 $0.38 1/16/16 HEB Best Multi-Topping: 2nd Place (Tied)
California Pizza Kitchen – Signature Pepperoni 9.5 $5.86 $0.43 5/5/16 HEB Best Pepperoni: 2nd Place
Bon Appetit – Mozzarella & Pesto 9.5 $4.98 $0.38 2/28/17 HEB
American Flatbread – Sliced Tomato & 5 Cheese 9.5 $5.98 $0.70 2/22/17 HEB
Home Run Inn – Margherita Sausage 9.5 $5.98 $0.18 4/11/17 HEB
Dr Oetker – Pepperoni Pesto 9.5 $3.98 $0.31 4/26/17 HEB Best Multi-Topping: Honorable Mention
Dr Oetker/Ristorante – Spinach 9.5 $3.98 $0.29 1/19/16 HEB Best Multi-Topping: Honorable Mention
Bon Appetit – Spinaci 9.5 $4.98 $0.32 1/13/16 HEB Best Multi-Topping: Honorable Mention
Home Run Inn – Pepperoni 9.5 $6.98 $0.26 1/12/16 HEB Best Pepperoni: 2nd Place
Mia Fresca – Pepperoni & Garlic 9 $5.97 $0.45 5/9/17 Walmart
Central Market HEB – Goat Cheese & Sauteed Vegetables 9 $4.98 $0.34 5/14/16 HEB
Central Market HEB – Four Cheese 9 $4.98 $0.35 6/8/16 HEB
Central Market HEB – Cherry Tomatoes and Spinach 9 $4.98 $0.35 9/11/16 HEB
Home Run Inn – Meat Lover’s Pizza 9 $6.98 $0.22 3/28/16 HEB
Home Run Inn – Cheese 9 $6.98 $0.26 2/26/16 HEB
Full of Life Flatbread – Cheese & Fresh Herb Pizza 9 $6.99 $0.92 1/13/16 Target
Artichoke Basille’s Pizza Co. – The Artichoke Pie 9 $6.98 $0.38 1/13/16 HEB Unique
Home Run Inn – Deluxe (Ultra Thin) 9 $6.98 $0.32 8/15/16 HEB Best Multi-Topping: Honorable Mention
Central Market HEB – Amalfi Coast 9 $4.98 $0.36 10/4/16 HEB
Sam’s Choice – Sriracha Chicken 9 $5.98 $0.19 1/21/17 Walmart Unique
Home Run Inn – Personal Microwavable Pizza 9 $2.98 $0.38 1/14/17 HEB
[Non-Frozen] HEB Made in Store – Margherita 9 $7.99 $0.46 6/3/17 HEB
Dr Oetker Virtuoso – Classic Crust Pepperoni 9 $4.98 $0.33 2/24/18 HEB Best Pepperoni: Honorable Mention
Urban Pie Mission District Pizza – Uncured Pepperoni & Sliced Chicken Sausage 8.5 $6.99 $0.34 7/7/16 HEB
Austin’s Pizza – Pepperoni 8.5 $8.99 $0.49 5/27/16 HEB
Tombstone – El Diablo 8.5 $3.97 $0.20 2/3/16 HEB
Austin’s Pizza – Brazos 8.5 $8.99 $0.40 12/1/16 HEB
Great Value Pizzadilla – Mexican Style 8.5 $6.98 $0.21 12/18/16 Walmart Unique
Garden Harvest by Uno – Uncured Pepperoni on Sweet Potato Crust 8.5 $5.98 $0.47 1/7/17 HEB Unique
Urban Pie Mission District Pizza – North End 8.5 $6.98 $0.41 8/26/17 HEB Unique
Central Market HEB – Margherita 8.2 $4.98 $0.33 3/30/17 HEB
Dr Oetker – Pizza Pollo 8 $3.98 $0.32 12/3/16 HEB
Screamin’ Sicilian – Lots of Pepperonis 8 $6.98 $0.31 7/4/17 HEB Best Pepperoni: Honorable Mention
Dr Oetker – Funghi 8 $3.98 $0.31 12/19/17 HEB
Sasquatch Pizza Co. – Triple Pepperoni 8 $9.99 $0.21 1/26/16 Walmart Best Party Pizza
Gino’s East – Sausage & Uncured Pepperoni 8 $5.98 $0.19 9/5/16 HEB
Kirkland Signature – Pepperoni 8 $3.12 $0.16 5/16/16 Costco Best Value
Sam’s Choice – Pepperoni 7 $7.98 $0.21 6/10/17 Walmart
California Pizza Kitchen – Fire Roasted Vegetables 7 $5.86 $0.41 7/18/17 HEB
Amy’s Pizza – Vegan Margherita with Daiya Cheese 7 $5.98 $0.44 3/10/16 HEB
Hill Country Fare – all 7 $2.48 $0.12 1/23/16 HEB Best Value: Honorable Mention
Kashi – Mushroom Trio & Spinach 7 $4.78 $0.40 1/14/16 HEB
Russo’s – Greek 7 $7.99 $0.59 1/14/16 HEB
California Pizza Kitchen – The Works 7 $5.86 $0.36 1/13/16 HEB
Tandoor Chef – Margherita 7 $3.48 $0.45 12/17/15 HEB
California Pizza Kitchen – Queso Fundido with Chorizo (Crispy Thin) 7 $5.86 $0.42 8/31/16 HEB Unique
SkinnyPizza – Ultra Thin & Crispy Uncured Pepperoni 7 $6.47 $0.60 11/15/17 HEB
Jeno’s – Pepperoni 6.5 $1.00 $0.20 1/23/16 HEB
Totino’s – Supreme 6.5 $1.35 $0.12 1/23/16 HEB
Amy’s Pizza – Spinach 6.5 $5.32 $0.38 1/14/16 HEB
Central Market HEB – Artichoke & Peppers 6.5 $4.98 $0.35 10/6/16 HEB
Dr Oetker Virtuoso – Rising Crust Margherita? 6.5 $4.98 $0.32 2/24/18 HEB
Market Pantry – Rising Crust Pepperoni 6 $4.69 $0.17 6/17/17 Target
Udi’s Gluten Free – Uncured Pepperoni 6 $5.76 $0.57 5/5/16 HEB Gluten-Free
Daiya – Mushroom & Roasted Garlic 6 $9.38 $0.55 4/18/16 HEB Gluten-Free
HEB Classic Selections – Self Rising Pepperoni 6 $4.25 $0.15 1/23/16 HEB
American Flatbread – Pulled Pork, Pineapple & Jalapeno 6 $6.98 $0.56 3/14/17 HEB
Tombstone – Pepperoni 5.5 $3.48 $0.17 1/19/16 HEB
Screamin’ Sicilian – Spicy Clucker 5 $6.98 $0.32 5/30/17 HEB Biggest Disappointment: Honorable Mention
Archer Farms – Greek-Inspired Spinach & Feta Cheese 5 $4.99 $0.33 10/14/17 Target
Economax – Supreme 5 $0.85 $0.16 1/19/16 HEB
Gino’s East – Meaty Legend 5 $5.98 $0.19 1/13/16 HEB
Fight’N Tomato – Chorizo & Jalapeno 5 $5.96 $0.23 9/8/17 HEB
California Pizza Kitchen – California Style White (Hand Tossed) 4 $5.86 $0.37 3/5/16 HEB
Tony’s – Pepperoni 4 $2.78 $0.15 1/16/15 HEB
Vito & Nicks II – Sausage & Mushroom 4 $9.99 $0.33 12/31/16 HEB
Digiorno – Spinach, Mushroom & Garlic 4 $5.47 $0.18 6/27/17 HEB Biggest Disappointment: Honorable Mention
Fight’N Tomato – Pepperoni Pizza 4 $5.96 $0.23 7/9/17 HEB
Mama Rosa’s – Pepperoni 3 $5.48 $0.13 5/14/16 HEB
California Pizza Kitchen – White (Crispy Thin) 3 $5.86 $0.44 1/16/16 HEB Biggest Disappointment
Ellio’s – Pepperoni 2 $2.98 $0.16 1/19/16 HEB Worst Pizza
Advertisements